Showing posts with label Gates. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gates. Show all posts

Sunday, April 22, 2007

Between Iraq and a hard place

Phillip Carter at Intel Dump:
Speaking to reporters today while traveling in Egypt, Defense Secretary Robert Gates expressed grave concern over the potential collapse of Iraq's government. According to the Times, Gates said that a failed state in Iraq “will be felt in the capitals and communities of the Middle East well before they are felt in Washington or New York . . . The forces that would be unleashed -- of sectarian strife, of an emboldened extremist movement with access to sanctuaries -- do not recognize national boundaries.” Which leaves America, well, stuck between Iraq and a hard place. What do we do now?
In another article, Carter explains:
This, then, is a story about when and how — not if — the Washington clock runs down. If Bush is successful, the time on that clock will expire after the November 2008 election, when he passes the Iraq problem to the next president and surrenders his legacy to history. Democrats are determined to make the sands run out on Bush's "surge" strategy much sooner — the better to begin the long homeward march of U.S. troops on the watch of the president who sent them to Iraq in the first place.
What U.S. military experts know about those discordant timelines, but what many of their fellow Americans seem to hardly grasp, is that regardless of when it occurs, the expiration of the political clock will not be the end. Rather, it will mark the beginning of the most challenging and potentially calamitous phase of the Iraq war.

"There's an old military adage that the most dangerous and hazardous of all military maneuvers is a withdrawal of forces while in contact with the enemy. That's the operation all of us soldiers fear the most," retired Maj. Gen. Robert Scales, a former commandant of the Army War College, told National Journal.

Some experts argue that the withdrawal of U.S. forces from Iraq will remove a major irritant and thus facilitate a resolution to the conflict, Scales noted, and others believe that a U.S. pullout could prompt chaos, massive bloodletting, and even genocide. "And if anyone insists that they know which it will be," he said, "they are lying. The truth is, we don't have enough understanding or insight into the thousands of intangibles to know what forces will drive the dynamic inside Iraq once we begin pulling out."As I see it, there are three questions open for discussion:
1) How much time does Gen. Petraeus and his team have left on the clock? (And in this case, the time is a function of domestic political calculus here in the U.S.)

2) What does Plan G look like? Is it (a) a transition to an advisory model, as a step towards withdrawal; (b) a slow withdrawal via the unit rotation process; or (c) a rapid withdrawal where everyone walks/drives/flies to the nearest border?

3) What happens to Iraq after we leave?
The presidential candidate who answers these three questions — and sells the answer to the American public — will win in 2008.


It also means that al-Maliki could be dumped (so much for free elections) and Allawi will be brought back in. Quoting the Asia Times via this post:
Ultimately, what unites Muqtada and Maliki is much more than what divides them. Both want a theocracy in Iraq. Both want the Americans to leave - although with different degrees of urgency. And both would dread a post-Maliki regime because most probably it would mean the return of former premier Iyad Allawi, who has promised to launch a deadly war against sectarianism, militias and Muqtada.

His record speaks for itself; he launched a bloody war against the Sadrists when he serving as prime minister in 2004. Sectarian politicians like Muqtada and Maliki dread the coming of the secular Allawi, who has frantically been trying to put together a coalition and convince both Arab regimes and the US administration to give him another go.

Muqtada, who has referred to Allawi as "the unbeliever who will soon succeed Maliki", sees Allawi as waiting for an opportune moment to strike at him and Maliki. He said, "We represent the majority of the country that does not want Iraq turned into a secular state and a slave of the Western powers, as Allawi dreams to the contrary."

As far as Muqtada and Maliki are concerned, they are willing to work with the devil - or each other - to defeat Allawi.

Friday, April 20, 2007

Iran would not arm the Taliban in Afghanistan

The Taliban represent everything that Iran is against. So weapons being used in Afghanistan and Iraq that have Iranian sources come from Iran's support of the Northern Alliance (remember them?).

Yet the Bush administration still wants to tie the two together for reasons all their own: (my bold)
Gates was categorical about Iranian government involvement. He then proceeded to discuss the Iranian government's Afghan policy. Gates said, "We don't know at what level this has been approved by the Iranian government or in the Iranian government. We don't know the magnitude of the assistance. It's obviously troubling and worrisome that the Iranians may be deciding to counter the efforts of some 42 nations in Afghanistan to establish a strong democratic state. So we'll watch it very closely."

Evidently, Gates went overboard by inviting the US's allies and friends to join in his condemnation of Tehran. Indeed, it strains credulity that the Iranian government has taken a virtual u-turn in its policy toward the Taliban. Iran is a big player in Afghanistan. It has thoughtfully exploited any new opportunities in the past five years to spread its influence and ideas within Afghanistan. Iran has pursued a nuanced strategy where various elements and policy instruments have been brought into almost optimal interplay - reconstruction, education, propaganda, good-neighborliness, trade, investment, economic interdependence and religion and ethnicity.
[snip]
Tehran understands that despite the talk of a "diplomatic solution", Bush is ratcheting up tensions. Given the Democratic Party's close links with the Israeli lobby, it endorses Vice President Dick Cheney's line that "all options are on the table" when it comes to making Iran bend. In such a dangerous scenario, Tehran will not act impetuously. Persians do not behave like Texan cowboys - "my-enemy's-enemy-is-my-friend". It is illogical that Iran would open a new front in Afghanistan, either.

Besides, Iran estimates carefully that any link-up with the Taliban (and al-Qaeda), howsoever tactical, could have unforeseen long-term consequences. Also, Iranians have a fairly accurate assessment of the complexities of the US's dealings with the Taliban. Iranians have all long suspected that there is a convergence of interests between the US, Britain and Pakistan to keep the Afghan war going at a certain level of intensity as a justification for perpetuating the Western military presence in the region.

Without doubt, Tehran realizes that continued American occupation of Afghanistan is irreconcilable with its vital interests and core concerns. But, at the same time, Afghanistan's long-term stability is of utmost concern to Tehran. Thus, the Iranian reaction to the US support for terrorism will be measured and proportionate. The Iranians know that the Afghan war is largely a war dominated by spin.

Sunday, February 11, 2007

Things that make you go hmmm... or aaaarrrggghhh depending

This article:

Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the Iranian president, has marked the 28th anniversary of Iran's revolution by pledging to maintain the country's nuclear programme, but adding that he wanted to remain within international rules.

"We are ready for talks, but will not suspend our activities," he said in a speech broadcast on state television on Sunday.

Along with this article:

Vladimir Putin, the Russian president, has arrived in Saudi Arabia on the first leg of a three-day tour of the Middle East aimed at building energy and military ties with traditional US allies.

The tour began a day after Iran asked Putin to block any UN resolutions passed against it when a deadline to halt nuclear work expires on February 21.

Along with this article:

MUNICH, Feb. 10 -- Russian President Vladimir Putin, in some of his harshest criticism of the United States since he took office seven years ago, said Saturday that Washington's unilateral, militaristic approach had made the world a more dangerous place than at any time during the Cold War.

"The United States has overstepped its national borders in every way," he said in an address at an annual international security conference here. "Nobody feels secure anymore, because nobody can take safety behind the stone wall of international law."
Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

Although the US brushed off the criticism:

But Washington has clearly decided to politely brush aside Mr Putin's remarks rather than to escalate tensions with Russia.

Making his first appearance at the conference as the new US Defence Secretary, Robert Gates tried to deflate President Putin's attack by poking a bit of fun at their past careers as spies.

"As an old Cold Warrior," he said, "one of yesterday's speakers almost filled me with nostalgia for a less complex time. Almost.

" Many of you have backgrounds in diplomacy or politics. I have, like your second speaker yesterday, a starkly different background - a career in the spy business.

"And, I guess, old spies have a habit of blunt speaking"

Mr Gates bluntly said there was no new Cold War and that the US certainly did not want one.

We know that the PNAC neocons remember fondly the good old days when the USSR was the evil empire, defense spending unquestioned, and the world chess board game was easier to play than fighting stateless terrorism. Condi's 'strength' was purportedly the Soviet Union. Could they thinking 'wouldn't it be nice to go back to the 1960s'?

Or are they still working on the old plan to piss everyone in the world off?

Update: This is interesting: (my bold)

It is seldom that the Russian president is publicly contradicted by officials in Moscow. But in the Russian reaction to Tehran's proposal for formal cooperation among the major gas-producing countries, it happened.

Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei conveyed the Iranian suggestion to the visiting secretary general of Russia's National Security Council, Igor Ivanov, in Tehran on January 28. The next day, Russia's Gazprom reacted in Moscow that "establishing a gas OPEC [Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries] is impossible because of different structuring of the oil and gas business".

A spokesman of the Russian Economic Development and Trade Ministry also reacted sharply: "I do not understand why Russia would need to create a gas cartel - I do not see any sense in it. The more so as Iran is now coming under serious external pressure." The official asked: "Why should we undertake commitments to synchronize our actions, why force ourselves into regulatory frameworks which could boil down to setting quotas?"

Then came a structured Russian position when Ivanov put the Iranian proposal in perspective at a press briefing in Moscow this Tuesday. He said the Iranian side mentioned the idea "not as a question or proposal for discussion, but as a general idea that natural-gas producers should seek such forms of cooperation, which fully supports their interests. As far as I know, no talks on setting up a cartel are under way."

But two days later, at a press conference in Moscow, President Vladimir Putin took a giant leap forward. He said, "A gas OPEC is an interesting idea, and we will think about it. In this initial stage we will agree with the Iranian specialists, with our Iranian partners and with some of the other countries that are large suppliers of fossil fuels, above all gas, to world markets, and we are already trying to coordinate our activities on the markets of third countries. We plan to continue doing so in future."

Putin added, "We have no plans to create some kind of a cartel, but I think it would be a good idea to coordinate our activities, especially in the context of achieving our main aim of ensuring a certain and reliable supply of energy resources for our main consumers."
However, five days later, Russian Energy Minister Viktor Khristenko was still at Square 1. "Fantasies about cartels and 'gas OPECs' are products of a sick imagination," he said.

So what's the problem? First, Moscow wanted to see that alarm bells didn't ring in Western capitals, especially when a top-level European Union delegation was due to visit Moscow. In the West, sweat breaks out at the very mention of "cartel", invoking images of production quotas, price rigging, and so on. Second, Moscow knows that a "gas OPEC" is still a decade away from realization, given the regional structure of the market, absence of a floating gas price (gas is mostly price-indexed to petroleum), double dependency resulting from the transportation through pipelines (gas-carrier ships are nowhere near meeting the needs of transportation) and the prevalence of long-term contracts between the supplier and the consumer, and, of course, the absence of a developed gas-liquefaction infrastructure.

Third, a masterly stroke in ambiguity doesn't do Russian interests any harm. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization has visualized that it is a matter of time before a "gas OPEC" takes shape. On the sidelines of the last NATO summit, in Latvia in November, there were calls for the formation of a "gas NATO" that is geared to safeguarding the energy security of Western consumer countries.

Thanks to Russian ingenuity, between the illusion and the reality of a "gas OPEC" a gray zone has appeared, with no certainty that this zone will not incrementally become the reality itself.

[snip]

Clearly, Tehran has sized up the growing assertiveness in Russian regional policies and is keen to harness it geopolitically. But more important, Tehran has signaled to European capitals that they may have to pay a heavy price for any further identification with the US policy toward Iran. The fact that the

Iranian proposal on the "gas OPEC" as made by spiritual leader Khamenei should leave Western capitals in no doubt that Tehran is not scoring a propaganda point. They must now rethink before imposing unilateral sanctions on Iran.

Iran is the "last frontier" for European countries seeking to access natural gas from the Middle East. By 2015-20, Europe will face serious gas shortages, even if Russia augments its supplies via the Northern European pipeline. Tehran knows it is a "special case" for European countries. Tehran was hoping all along that it could normalize relations with the European Union, and that it would receive serious economic and political carte blanche.

NTodd at Dohiyi Mir notes the similarities between Bush and Putin, both of them 'vile, anti-democratic creatures'.

Friday, February 02, 2007

Who are you going to believe? Me or your lying eyes?

Gates says we're not planning a war with Iran:

At his news conference, Gates also said that the decision announced in January to send a second U.S. aircraft carrier to the Persian Gulf region does not mean the United States is planning for a war with Iran. He said the purpose was to underscore to U.S. allies as well as potential adversaries that the Gulf is a vital interest to the United States.

"Nobody is planning, we are not planning for a war with Iran," Gates said.

Gates said the United States' main aim with regard to Iranian influence inside Iraq is to counter what he called networks providing explosives used to make roadside bombs that are powerful enough to destroy a U.S. tank.

"Because we are acting against the Iranians' activities in Iraq, it has given rise to some of these talks" of U.S. intentions to attack Iran, he said, adding that there is no such plan.

Pace said that over the past month or so, raids against those bomb-supplying networks had netted two Iranians.

But we know that Bush, Cheney and all the drooling PNAC neocons are so close...so... close to their wet dreams of imperial domination of the world. They can't let this last chance get away.

Thursday, December 28, 2006

Gates not on the same page as Dear Leader?

Josh Marshall:
"Gates lacking the urge to surge? This is interesting. In yesterday's New York Sun, Eli Lake reports that Sec Def Robert Gates is actually quietly opposing President Bush's plan to escalate the conflict by adding 30,000 to 50,000 more troops to crush the Mahdi Army and other Shi'a militias in and around Baghdad."

Update: Via Atrios and Editor&Publisher, AP says the soldiers aren't too hot on it either.

Sinfonian has more.

Wednesday, November 22, 2006

Gates and Iran-Contra.

Laura Rozen: (my bold)
"former CIA Soviet analyst Jennifer Glaudemans on Robert Gates and the politicization of intelligence:
In 1985...Iran-Contra was in the planning stages then, a secret scheme in which the Reagan administration was going to sell arms to an enemy country, Iran, and use the proceeds to fund the anti-communist Contras in Nicaragua.

In order to justify these actions, administration officials felt they needed some analytical backing from the intelligence community. Those in my office knew nothing of their plans, of course, but it was the context in which we were asked, in 1985, to contribute to the National Intelligence Estimate on the subject of Iran.

Later, when we received the draft NIE, we were shocked to find that our contribution on Soviet relations with Iran had been completely reversed. Rather than stating that the prospects for improved Soviet-Iranian relations were negligible, the document indicated that Moscow assessed those prospects as quite good. What's more, the national intelligence officer responsible for coordinating the estimate had already sent a personal memo to the White House stating that the race between the U.S. and USSR "for Tehran is on, and whoever gets there first wins all."

No one in my office believed this Cold War hyperbole. ...

We protested the conclusions of the NIE, citing evidence such as the Iranian government's repression of the communist Tudeh Party, the expulsion of all Soviet economic advisors and a number of Soviet diplomats who were KGB officers, and a continuing public rhetoric that chastised the "godless" communist regime as the "Second Satan" after the United States.

Despite overwhelming evidence, our analysis was suppressed. At a coordinating meeting, we were told that Gates wanted the language to stay in as it was, presumably to help justify "improving" our strained relations with Tehran through the Iran-Contra weapons sales."